Residents’ Rights, Ethics, and the Law

Chapter 2: Residents’ Rights, Ethics, and the Law

Learning Objectives

  1. Name the main residents' rights protected by federal law (OBRA) and give an example of honoring each one in daily care.
  2. Explain confidentiality and HIPAA, and spot everyday situations that violate a resident's privacy.
  3. Recognize the types and signs of abuse, neglect, and misappropriation of property.
  4. Describe your duty to report suspected abuse, neglect, or exploitation, including when and to whom you report.
  5. Tell legal duties from ethical ones, and recognize negligence and the limits of your role.

Imagine moving out of your home and into a building where strangers help you bathe, dress, and use the toilet. Someone else decides when meals are served. People you have never met walk into your room. For many residents of nursing homes, this is daily life. Their rights are what keep this life dignified. Those rights do not end at the front door of a care facility.

As a nurse assistant, you are the person residents see most often. That makes you the person most able to protect their rights, and the person most able to violate them, even by accident. Knocking before you enter, keeping a resident's diagnosis to yourself, and speaking up when something looks wrong are all part of the job. They are also some of the most tested topics on the knowledge exam.

This chapter covers residents' rights, privacy, abuse and neglect, your legal duty to report, and the ethics that guide everyday care. In this book, "resident" means a person living in a long-term care facility. Hospitals use the word "patient," and home care agencies say "client." The rights and duties in this chapter apply to all of them.

2.1 Residents' Rights

2.1.1 Where residents' rights come from

In 1987, Congress passed a law called the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act, usually shortened to OBRA. Part of OBRA set rules for nursing homes that receive Medicare or Medicaid money, which is almost all of them. OBRA set minimum training for nurse assistants (that is why you are taking a course and a state exam). It also created a list of rights that every nursing home resident has.

Facilities must tell residents about their rights, both in writing and out loud, when they are admitted. The rights are usually posted where residents and visitors can see them. If a resident cannot make decisions, a legal representative, such as a guardian or a person named in a power of attorney, can act for them.

OBRA (Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1987) — The federal law that sets standards for nursing homes, including residents' rights and the training and testing of nurse assistants.

Residents' rights — The legal rights every resident of a long-term care facility keeps, such as the right to dignity, privacy, choice, and freedom from abuse and restraints.

The sections below cover the rights you will deal with most often. Notice a pattern: each right is about the resident being treated as an adult who runs their own life.

2.1.2 The right to be treated with dignity and respect

Dignity means a person's sense of worth and self-respect. You protect dignity in small ways all day long:

2.1.3 The right to make choices

Residents have the right to self-determination, which means making their own decisions about their life and care. They can choose:

Choice includes the right to say no. If Mrs. Alvarez refuses her shower, you may not force her, trick her, or threaten her. You can explain why the shower is helpful, ask whether a different time would work better, or offer a bed bath instead. If she still refuses, respect her choice and report the refusal to the nurse. The nurse may need to talk with her, update the care plan, or find out whether something is wrong, such as pain or fear of falling.

Exam tip: When a test question says a resident refuses care, the best answer is almost never "do it anyway" or "skip it and say nothing." Look for the answer that respects the refusal, tries to find out why, and reports it to the nurse.

2.1.4 The right to privacy

Residents have the right to privacy in their care, their personal space, their mail and phone calls, and their visits. Practical ways to protect privacy include:

The privacy of a resident's information is covered in the next section.

2.1.5 The right to personal possessions

Residents may keep and use their own belongings, such as clothing, photos, furniture, and other items, as space and safety allow. These things make a room feel like home. Handle them with care. Ask before you move or throw anything away, even something that looks like trash. Belongings are usually listed on an inventory when a resident moves in. Missing items must be reported, because losing or taking a resident's things can be a form of mistreatment (see "Misappropriation of property" later in this chapter).

Residents also have the right to manage their own money, or to have the facility help manage it if they choose.

2.1.6 The right to voice complaints

Residents and families may complain about care without being punished for it. A resident who complains must not be ignored, given worse care, or treated coldly. This is called freedom from retaliation, which means getting back at someone.

If a resident complains to you, listen, take it seriously, and tell the nurse. Each state also has a long-term care ombudsman program. An ombudsman is an advocate, separate from the facility, who helps residents solve problems and protect their rights. Residents may contact the ombudsman at any time, and you must never discourage them.

Ombudsman — An advocate, independent of the facility, who investigates residents' complaints and helps protect their rights.

2.1.7 Freedom from abuse and from restraints

Residents have the right to be free from abuse, neglect, mistreatment, and involuntary seclusion. These are covered in detail later in this chapter.

They also have the right to be free from restraints used for discipline (punishment) or staff convenience. A restraint is anything that limits a person's freedom to move or to reach their own body, and that the person cannot easily remove. A physical restraint can be a vest, a belt, a tray table locked onto a wheelchair, or even bed rails or a chair the person cannot get out of. A chemical restraint is a drug given to control behavior rather than to treat a medical condition.

Under federal rules, a restraint may be used only when it is needed to treat a medical symptom, and then the least restrictive option should be used for the shortest time possible.1 Restraints require a doctor's order and are a last resort. They can cause serious harm, including injuries, pressure injuries, loss of strength, and death by strangulation. You will learn about restraint risks and alternatives in Chapter 5. Safety and Emergency Care.

Never apply a restraint on your own, even if a resident keeps trying to get up. Using a restraint without an order is false imprisonment and abuse. Report the behavior to the nurse instead.

2.1.8 Other rights to know

Residents also have the right to:

2.2 Privacy and Confidentiality

2.2.1 What confidentiality means

Confidentiality means keeping private information private. Everything you learn about a resident while you work, such as their diagnosis, medications, family problems, money, or behavior, is confidential. You share it only with people on the care team who need it to give care.

The federal law that protects health information is HIPAA, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996. HIPAA's Privacy Rule protects a person's protected health information, or PHI. PHI is any health information that can identify a person. A name, an address, a birth date, a room number, a photo, or a medical record number linked to health information all count.

HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) — The federal law that protects the privacy and security of a person's health information.

Protected health information (PHI) — Any information about a person's health, care, or payment for care that can identify that person.

2.2.2 The "need to know" rule

Ask yourself one question before you share or look at any resident information: Does this person need to know this to give care?

Looking at records you don't need for your work is a HIPAA violation, even if you never tell anyone what you saw. Electronic records keep track of who opens each chart, so this kind of snooping is often caught.

If a family member or visitor asks you about a resident's condition, politely refer them to the nurse. The nurse knows who the resident has allowed to receive information. A good answer is, "I'm not able to share that, but I'll ask the nurse to talk with you."

2.2.3 Everyday privacy mistakes

Most privacy violations are not dramatic. They happen in ordinary moments:

Never post, text, or share photos of residents, even with permission from a coworker, and never share your computer password. A single post can cost you your job and lead to legal action.

2.2.4 Privacy has limits: when you must share

Confidentiality never means keeping secrets that could hurt the resident. If a resident tells you, "Don't tell anyone, but my son takes my money," or "I want to end my life," you must report it to the nurse right away. You can be honest with the resident: "I care about you, and I can't keep this to myself. I need to tell the nurse so we can help." Never promise to keep a secret.

Exam tip: Questions about privacy often have one answer that "keeps the resident's secret." When the secret involves harm, abuse, or a change in condition, that answer is wrong. Reporting to the nurse protects the resident and does not violate HIPAA.

2.3 Abuse, Neglect, and Mistreatment

2.3.1 What counts as abuse

Abuse is harming a person on purpose. It does not matter whether the person who did it meant to cause injury; the act itself was willful. Federal rules say residents must be free from physical, verbal, mental, and sexual abuse, and from corporal punishment (punishment that hurts the body) and involuntary seclusion.2 Abuse can come from staff, family members, visitors, or other residents.

Abuse — The willful infliction of injury, unreasonable confinement, intimidation, or punishment that results in physical harm, pain, or mental anguish. It also includes depriving a person of goods or services they need.

Learn each type and its signs:

Type What it looks like Possible signs
Physical abuse Hitting, slapping, pinching, pushing, kicking, rough handling, or force-feeding Bruises (especially in odd places or shapes, such as finger marks), burns, cuts, broken bones, injuries that don't match the explanation
Verbal abuse Yelling, swearing, name-calling, threats, or insulting language, spoken or written, including within the resident's hearing Resident seems afraid, withdrawn, tearful, or anxious around certain people
Mental or emotional abuse Humiliating, threatening, ignoring, or teasing a resident; taking photos or videos that demean them Fear, depression, agitation, sudden changes in behavior, not wanting to be left with a person
Sexual abuse Any sexual contact or behavior without consent, including touching, exposure, or sexual comments; a person who cannot give consent cannot agree to sex Bruising or bleeding in the genital area, torn or stained underwear, new sexually transmitted infection, fear of being touched during care
Financial abuse (exploitation) Stealing or misusing a resident's money or property, or pressuring them to sign papers or give gifts Missing money or belongings, unpaid bills, sudden changes to a will or bank account, a "new best friend" who controls the resident's money
Involuntary seclusion Separating a resident from others, or confining them to a room or area, against their will Resident kept in a room, kept away from activities or visitors, or not allowed to leave an area

2.3.2 Neglect

Neglect is failing to give the goods and services a person needs to avoid physical harm, pain, or mental distress. Neglect may be on purpose or not, and it is still harmful either way. Examples include:

Signs of neglect include pressure injuries, weight loss, dehydration, poor hygiene, odor, long fingernails, and a resident who seems hungry, thirsty, or ignored.

Neglect — The failure to provide goods and services a person needs to avoid physical harm, pain, mental anguish, or emotional distress.

2.3.3 Misappropriation of property

Misappropriation means taking or using a resident's belongings or money without permission, whether by stealing them or by "borrowing" them. Using a resident's phone, eating snacks their family brought, or wearing a sweater from their closet are all misappropriation, even if you meant to give the item back. A finding of misappropriation, like a finding of abuse, can end your career as a nurse assistant.

2.3.4 Mistreatment and other forms of harm

Mistreatment is a broad term for inappropriate treatment or exploitation of a resident. It covers things like using a restraint for staff convenience, giving a drug to control behavior without a medical reason, or making a resident wait for care as punishment.

Domestic violence (abuse by a spouse or partner) and elder abuse happen outside facilities too. If you work in home care, watch for signs of abuse by family members or other caregivers, as well as self-neglect, when a person can no longer care for themselves.

2.3.5 Why residents are at risk, and why some stay silent

Many residents depend on others for care. Some have dementia (see Chapter 12. Dementia and Mental Health), hearing loss, or trouble speaking, so they cannot easily tell anyone what happened. Others are afraid that complaining will make things worse, or they feel ashamed. Some don't want to get a family member in trouble. This is why you must watch for signs, not wait for a resident to tell you.

Also watch yourself. Caregiving is stressful. If you notice that you are becoming impatient, rough, or angry with a resident, step away (after making sure the resident is safe), and ask the nurse or another nurse assistant for help. Taking care of your own stress is part of preventing abuse.

2.4.1 Your duty to report

If you see, hear about, or suspect abuse, neglect, exploitation, or mistreatment, you must report it. You do not need proof. You do not need to be sure. A reasonable suspicion is enough. Investigating is someone else's job; reporting is yours.

What to do when you suspect abuse:

  1. Make sure the resident is safe. If you walk in on abuse happening, stop it if you can do so safely, stay with the resident, and call for help.
  2. Report right away to the nurse or your supervisor, following your facility's policy. Do not wait until the end of your shift.
  3. Give the facts. Tell what you saw or heard, when, and who was involved. Use the resident's own words if they told you something.
  4. Don't confront the person you suspect, and don't try to investigate on your own.
  5. Don't discuss it with coworkers, other residents, or family. Keep it confidential.

Federal rules require nursing homes to report every alleged violation involving abuse, neglect, exploitation, mistreatment, injuries of unknown source, and misappropriation of resident property to the administrator and to state officials. The facility must report immediately and no later than 2 hours after the allegation is made if the events involve abuse or result in serious bodily injury, and no later than 24 hours otherwise.3 These short timelines are why you must report the moment you suspect something, not later.

2.4.2 Reporting in Utah

Utah law goes further than facility policy. It puts a duty on every individual, not just health care workers. If you have reason to believe a vulnerable adult (an older adult or an adult with a physical or mental impairment) is being, or has been, abused, neglected, or exploited, you must immediately report it to Adult Protective Services (APS) or to the nearest police officer or law enforcement agency.4 Utah APS takes reports by phone at 1-800-371-7897 and through an online form. In an emergency, call 911.5

The same law protects people who report. A person who reports in good faith (honestly believing abuse may be happening) is immune from civil and criminal liability for making the report. A person who willfully fails to report can be charged with a misdemeanor.6

In practice, at work you report to your nurse or supervisor first, as your facility's policy says, and the facility makes its required reports. But your own legal duty does not go away. If you report and nothing is done, or if the person you would report to is the one involved, you can and should contact APS or law enforcement yourself.

Never let anyone talk you out of reporting suspected abuse, and never wait to "be sure" or to "gather more evidence." Delays put residents at risk and can make you part of the problem.

Exam tip: When a question asks what a nurse assistant should do first after seeing a coworker abuse a resident, look for "make sure the resident is safe" and "report to the nurse or supervisor immediately." Wrong answers usually involve confronting the coworker, waiting until the end of the shift, discussing it with other staff, or deciding it isn't serious enough to report.

2.4.3 The Nurse Aide Registry and abuse findings

Each state keeps a nurse aide registry, a list of nurse assistants who have passed training and testing. In Utah, this is the Utah Nursing Assistant Registry (see Chapter 1. The Role of the Nurse Assistant). Under federal rules, if the state investigates and finds that a nurse assistant abused or neglected a resident or misappropriated their property, that finding is placed on the nurse assistant's registry record. Facilities check the registry before hiring, so a finding can keep you from working as a nurse assistant again. A nurse assistant can also face criminal charges.

Laws are rules made by the government. Breaking them can lead to fines, loss of certification, lawsuits, or jail. Health care law uses several terms you need to recognize:

Negligence is failing to do what a reasonable, careful person with your training would do, causing harm. Negligence is usually not on purpose. Examples: forgetting to lock wheelchair brakes during a transfer and the resident falls, or leaving the bed in the high position and the resident rolls out. Malpractice is negligence by a licensed professional, such as a nurse or doctor. As a nurse assistant you are responsible for your own actions, and you can be sued for negligence.

Negligence — An unintentional failure to give the care a reasonable, careful person with the same training would give, resulting in harm to someone.

Other legal terms:

Informed consent means a person agrees to a treatment after being told, in words they understand, what it is, why it is being done, its risks and benefits, and the other choices they have. The doctor or nurse is responsible for getting informed consent for treatments and procedures. That is not part of a nurse assistant's job.

Your part is simpler but important: before you give any care, explain what you are going to do and get the resident's okay. If the resident refuses, don't go ahead. Report the refusal to the nurse. If a resident tells you they don't understand a treatment or have changed their mind about it, tell the nurse.

Informed consent — A person's agreement to treatment after being told what it involves, its risks and benefits, and the alternatives, in a way they can understand.

Some residents have advance directives, legal papers that state their wishes for care if they cannot speak for themselves. You will learn about these in Chapter 13. Comfort and End-of-Life Care.

2.5 Ethics in Daily Care

2.5.1 Law and ethics are not the same

Laws are rules set by the government, with penalties for breaking them. Ethics are standards of right and wrong conduct. Professions, including nursing, have codes of ethics that guide what workers should do even when no law applies.

Sometimes something is legal but not ethical. For example, no law says you must greet each resident warmly, but ignoring residents is not ethical care. Sometimes law and ethics overlap: stealing from a resident is both illegal and unethical.

Ethics — Standards of right and wrong conduct that guide how a person or profession behaves, even where no law applies.

2.5.2 Ethical principles in health care

Health care ethics rests on a few principles. You don't need to memorize the formal names for the exam, but you should be able to apply the ideas:

Here is how these play out. A nurse assistant who makes a mistake, such as giving a resident the wrong meal tray, reports it to the nurse right away instead of hiding it. That is honesty. A nurse assistant who gives the same gentle care to a grumpy resident as to a friendly one is practicing fairness.

2.5.3 Professional boundaries

A boundary is the line between a caring, professional relationship and a personal one. You should be warm and kind with residents, but your relationship exists to meet their needs, not yours. Crossing a boundary can confuse residents, create favoritism, and open the door to exploitation.

Stay within professional boundaries:

Professional boundaries — The limits that keep a caregiver's relationship with a resident focused on the resident's needs rather than the caregiver's.

2.5.4 Gifts and tips

Residents and families sometimes want to show thanks with money or gifts. It feels kind, and refusing can feel rude. But accepting gifts can look like you are taking advantage of someone, and it can lead to favoritism or worse. Most facilities do not allow nurse assistants to accept money, tips, or gifts.

If Mr. Reyes tries to hand you a $20 bill, thank him warmly and decline: "That's so kind of you, but I'm not allowed to accept gifts. Taking care of you is my job, and I enjoy it." Follow your facility's policy. Some allow small gifts shared with the whole staff, like a plate of cookies for the break room. When in doubt, ask your nurse or supervisor.

2.5.5 Respecting beliefs and cultures

Residents come from many cultures and faiths, and those affect food, modesty, hygiene, touch, family roles, and end-of-life wishes. For example, a resident may prefer a caregiver of the same gender for bathing, may not eat pork or beef, may fast on certain days, or may want family members present for decisions.

Respecting these differences is both an ethical duty and a residents' right. Don't judge, joke about, or try to change a resident's beliefs, and don't impose your own. If you're not sure what a resident prefers, ask them politely, and check the care plan. You will learn more about culture and religion in Chapter 7. Aging and Psychosocial Needs.

2.5.6 Staying within your scope

Ethics also means doing only what you are trained and allowed to do. If a resident or family member asks you to do a task outside your role, such as giving a medication, changing an oxygen setting, or making a decision about care, politely say no and tell the nurse. Doing tasks outside your scope of practice is unsafe and can be illegal. The chapter Chapter 1. The Role of the Nurse Assistant explains scope of practice in detail.

Exam tip: Many ethics questions come down to two ideas. The resident's choice comes first, and when you are unsure, you report to the nurse. If one answer respects the resident's wishes and keeps you within your role, it is probably the best one.

Check that they can recognize a violation of residents' rights or privacy (HIPAA) in an everyday situation, name the types and signs of abuse, neglect, and misappropriation, and say exactly what a nurse assistant does on suspecting abuse: keep the resident safe, report immediately to the nurse or supervisor, and know that Utah law also lets them report directly to Adult Protective Services. Probe the common mistake of confronting the suspected abuser, keeping a resident's "secret," or waiting for proof instead of reporting right away. For Apply, a resident's refusal of care, a gift offered by a family member, or a coworker posting about work on social media would fit.

2.6 Practice Questions

  1. A resident tells the nurse assistant she does not want her shower this morning. What should the nurse assistant do?
    • A. Give the shower anyway, because it is on the schedule
    • B. Tell the resident she will lose a privilege if she refuses
    • C. Respect her choice, ask if another time or a bed bath would work, and report the refusal to the nurse
    • D. Skip the shower and not mention it, since the resident made her choice
  2. Which action best protects a resident's privacy during personal care?
    • A. Leaving the door open so staff can find you if needed
    • B. Pulling the privacy curtain and uncovering only the area being washed
    • C. Talking with the roommate to distract the resident
    • D. Asking the resident's visitor to stay and help
  3. A nurse assistant's friend asks, "Is the mayor's mother in your nursing home? What's wrong with her?" The best response is:
    • A. "I can't share any information about residents."
    • B. "Yes, but I can only tell you she's doing fine."
    • C. "I'll tell you if you promise not to tell anyone."
    • D. "Ask her family; they'll know more than I do."
  4. While helping Mr. Lee dress, a nurse assistant notices bruises on both upper arms in the shape of fingers. Mr. Lee says he doesn't remember what happened. What should the nurse assistant do?
    • A. Wait to see if more bruises appear before reporting
    • B. Ask the other nurse assistants who has been rough with him
    • C. Document "resident was abused" in the chart
    • D. Report the bruises to the nurse right away
  5. A nurse assistant sees a coworker slap a resident. What should the nurse assistant do first?
    • A. Tell the coworker that slapping is not allowed
    • B. Make sure the resident is safe and report to the nurse or supervisor immediately
    • C. Report it at the end of the shift so the coworker can finish their work
    • D. Talk with other staff to find out if this has happened before
  6. A resident with dementia keeps trying to stand up from her wheelchair. Another nurse assistant suggests tying a sheet around her waist to keep her seated. This would be:
    • A. A restraint used for staff convenience, which is not allowed
    • B. Acceptable if it is only for a short time
    • C. A good way to prevent falls
    • D. Allowed if the resident's family agrees
  7. A nurse assistant forgets to lock the bed wheels during a transfer, and the resident falls and breaks a hip. This is an example of:
    • A. Assault
    • B. Negligence
    • C. Libel
    • D. Informed consent
  8. A resident's daughter offers the nurse assistant $50 as thanks for taking good care of her mother. What is the best response?
    • A. Accept it so the daughter is not offended
    • B. Accept it and share it with the other nurse assistants
    • C. Suggest she give it to the resident instead
    • D. Thank her kindly and politely decline, following facility policy
  9. A nurse assistant takes a resident's candy bar from his drawer, planning to replace it the next day. This is:
    • A. Acceptable if the nurse assistant replaces it
    • B. Involuntary seclusion
    • C. Misappropriation of resident property
    • D. A boundary issue only, not a rights issue
  10. A resident tells a nurse assistant, "My nephew keeps taking money from my purse, but please don't tell anyone. I don't want him in trouble." What should the nurse assistant do?
    • A. Explain gently that she must tell the nurse, and report it right away
    • B. Keep the secret to respect the resident's privacy
    • C. Confront the nephew the next time he visits
    • D. Tell the resident she must report it herself

2.6.1 Answers

  1. C. Residents have the right to refuse care. The nurse assistant respects the choice, looks for an acceptable alternative, and reports the refusal so the nurse can follow up.
  2. B. Closing the curtain and exposing only the part of the body being cared for protects privacy and dignity. The other choices expose the resident to others.
  3. A. Even confirming that a person is a resident shares protected information. Information is shared only with people who need it to give care.
  4. D. Finger-shaped bruises are a possible sign of physical abuse. You report suspected abuse right away; you don't need proof, and you don't investigate or chart conclusions.
  5. B. Protect the resident first, then report immediately. Confronting the coworker, delaying the report, or gossiping are all wrong.
  6. A. A sheet tied around the waist is a physical restraint. Restraints need a medical reason and an order and are a last resort; report the resident's behavior to the nurse instead.
  7. B. Negligence is an unintentional failure to give reasonable care that causes harm. Assault is a threat, and libel is written false statements.
  8. D. Accepting money can look like taking advantage of a resident and crosses professional boundaries. Decline kindly and follow facility policy.
  9. C. Taking or using a resident's belongings without permission is misappropriation, even if you plan to replace them.
  10. A. Financial exploitation must be reported. Never promise to keep a secret that involves harm; tell the resident honestly that you need to tell the nurse.


  1. 42 CFR § 483.12, "Freedom from abuse, neglect, and exploitation," paragraphs (a)(1), (a)(2), and (c)(1). https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/42/483.12↩︎

  2. 42 CFR § 483.12, "Freedom from abuse, neglect, and exploitation," paragraphs (a)(1), (a)(2), and (c)(1). https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/42/483.12↩︎

  3. 42 CFR § 483.12, "Freedom from abuse, neglect, and exploitation," paragraphs (a)(1), (a)(2), and (c)(1). https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/42/483.12↩︎

  4. Utah Code § 26B-6-205, "Reporting requirements," subsections (1), (7), and (9). https://codes.findlaw.com/ut/title-26b-utah-health-and-human-services-codes/ut-code-sect-26b-6-205/ (official text: https://le.utah.gov)↩︎

  5. Utah Division of Aging and Adult Services, "Adult Protective Services." https://daas.utah.gov/adult-protective-services/↩︎

  6. Utah Code § 26B-6-205, "Reporting requirements," subsections (1), (7), and (9). https://codes.findlaw.com/ut/title-26b-utah-health-and-human-services-codes/ut-code-sect-26b-6-205/ (official text: https://le.utah.gov)↩︎